Showing posts with label Chronicles of Narnia. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Chronicles of Narnia. Show all posts

Friday, August 31, 2012

AUDIO: The Voyage of the Dawn Treader by C. S. Lewis


I had only seen the movie version once, awhile ago, before listening to the audio version in this set. I knew the story included the two youngest Pevensies and an annoying cousin named Eustace who, at some point, turns into a dragon. I didn't remember much more; it didn't make a great impression. We watched the movie again after hearing the book, and I was disappointed at how much it strayed from the original source material!

The story itself seemed to drag a little as Caspian, Edmund, Lucy and Eustace went from island to island to island looking for the lost Lords of Telmar. There were times I thought they would never get to Aslan's land. The final leg of their trip seemed especially slow and drawn out. But if I had to choose between the more deliberate route covered by the book or the mashed up version they put in the movie, I would pick the book every time. I enjoyed the discovery aspects of the journey - they were all adventurers, striking out in largely uncharted territory. When my students ask for adventure books, I'm going to steer them to this one. I'll probably read chapter one with my writing club students to talk about writing with one's senses. This is a great example!

4 out of 5 stars
AR Rating of 5.9

Wednesday, August 29, 2012

AUDIO: Prince Caspian by C. S. Lewis


I have never read the Chronicles of Narnia. Every summer I promise I'm going to read them, and I never get around to it. This summer I decided I was going to do it, even if I had to let someone else do the work. So I bought this audio set and we have loved it!

We decided to listen to the books in publication order rather than the publisher's order. After reading pros and cons of each, that seemed best to me.

I found The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe to be slow. I don't know that I have ever read the book before, but I know the story line well enough that I really wanted things to move along a lot faster. But I found Prince Caspian to be delightful! So far, it is my favorite.

The story itself is a lot of flashbacks. The four Pevensie children are pulled into Narnia and meet a dwarf they don't know. The dwarf tells Caspian's story which, for being a flashback, is pretty engrossing. Then the kids enter the story already in progress, helping Caspian secure the thrown that is rightfully his. (My favorite part is when Miraz, the usurping king, is played by his advisors - that scene is masterfully written and masterfully performed.)

I've only seen the movie version once or twice, which is nice for a visual of some of the players, but I like the book far better (the added scene in the movie is atrocious, in my opinion).

If you already enjoy the Narnia stories, or if you like audio books in general, this is a great set!

4 out of 5 stars
AR Rating of 5.7